On behalf of the Corporate Stance Committee and the Congregation, I am pleased to announce that we have supported a corporate stance against the Death Penalty. Over 75% of the membership has voted and 97% of that group favors the recommendation put to us.
We used the expedited process found in our policy book, foregoing the area meeting process and immediate common study. As indicated in the materials sent to the membership, the committee felt we have had many opportunities in the past years to reflect on this issue.
Our commitment was framed by the document written by Franciscans International – Dominicans for Justice and Peace(text below). This document is based on the writings of Pope John Paul II and the Bishops of the United States to proclaim justice and to address the unjust structures that impede a just world order. The authors further drew upon the experiences of their prison chaplains and of their ministers working with families and friends of victims.
Our committee found the document to be consistent with our Direction Statement: To be open to encountering the Holy in ourselves, in each other and in people of all cultures and lifestyles. We also found it to be consistent with our own efforts to foster the Sanctity of Life as well as with our work and study for non-violence.
Our stance commits us to make public proclamations for life when and where they are needed and to preach the justice of our commitment. We will be called upon to work in coalition with other groups, to speak out at times of executions, to promote study and prayer in our places of ministry as well as among ourselves, and to call each other to needed and creative responses. Our first action will be to proclaim our Congregation as a supporter to the Document that will be submitted to the United Nations Subcommittee on Human Rights this August.
At this time, I present the approved document with supporting materials to Sister Maribeth Holst, our Prioress and Sister Maureen Geary, our Promoter of Justice and offer to them our cooperation and prayers in the furthering of this act of justice.
Presented at Eucharist: During Dominican Study Days, 2001
M. Brigid Clingman, OP, Councilor for Mission and Advocacy
FRANCISCANS INTERNATIONAL DOMINICANS FOR JUSTICE AND PEACE REPORT
A Call for the End to the Death Penalty Written Statement
For the 2001 Sub-Commission on the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights Franciscans International, in conjunction with Dominicans for Justice and Peace calls for the end to the death penalty, a penalty that is final and flawed, a penalty that, in many cases, reflects both racism and classism; a penalty from which there is no return, no redress; a penalty that certainly destroys the life of the person condemned, but almost certainly destroys those in whose name the punishment is enacted. We call on all governments to suspend all executions and to abolish the death penalty. We base this call on the writings of Pope John Paul II and of the Bishops of the United States . We base it on our commitment to proclaiming justice and to our history in working to address the unjust structures that impede a just world order. We further base it on the experience of our members in prison chaplaincy work and work with the families and friends of victims.
A sign of hope is the increasing recognition that the dignity of human life can never be taken away, even in the case of someone who has done great evil. Modern society has the means of protecting itself without definitively denying criminals the chance to reform. I renew the appeal I made most recently at Christmas for a consensus to end the death penalty, which is both cruel and unnecessary. (Pope John Paul II – 2000)
We ask all people of good will, particularly Catholics; to work to end capital punishment. . . we must commit ourselves to a persistent and principled witness against the death penalty, against a culture of death, and for the Gospel of life.(United States Catholic Bishops )
Since 1997, the United Nations Commission on Human Rights has adopted resolutions for a moratorium on the death penalty. At present, 109 of the 185 member states of the United Nations have called for an end to the death penalty or a moratorium on its practice. Articles 3 and 5 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UNDHR) state that every human being has the right to life, and the right not to be subjected to cruel and degrading punishment. These rights are inalienable and absolute and cannot depend on behavior. They are the rights of humans, simply, and profoundly, because they are human. To continue to enact the death penalty is to teach that violence and killing are acceptable ways of dealing with violence and killing.
According to Amnesty International, in the past decade more than three countries a year, on average, have abolished the death penalty. We are compelled to speak out because of the increased use of the death penalty and the state of the death penalty in the United States. By the year 2000, 683 human beings were executed since the death penalty was resumed in 1977. Over 3,700 prisoners in the United States were under sentence of death as of January 1, 2001. To date, 38 states in the United States provide for the death penalty in law; the death penalty is also provided for under United States federal military and civilian law. In calling for the abolition of the death penalty, we express concerns about its unjust and unequal application. In countries where the death penalty continues to be enacted, it is more likely to be applied in a racist manner, more likely to be applied to minorities and the underclasses in general. Poor people, disabled people and young people are more often subjected to capital punishment.
Execution of the Innocent
Since the reinstatement of the death penalty in the United States in 1977, 93 people in 22 states have been released from death row. Some have come very close to execution after spending many years in prison. Some prisoners have been executed despite serious doubts over their guilt.
Governor George Ryan of Illinois in the US has called a halt to executions in his state until he could be sure the death penalty was being administered fairly. The decision followed the exoneration of the 13th death row prisoner found to have been wrongfully convicted in the state of Illinois, since the USA reinstated the death penalty. Governor Ryan, who is a death penalty supporter, said there was too much evidence of past mistakes for the system to go unexamined and unchecked. Independent studies suggest that the death penalty does not lead to a decrease in capital crimes.
A study conducted by the United Nations in 1988 and updated in 1996 stated that “the fact that all the evidence continues to point in the same direction is persuasive a priori evidence that countries need not fear sudden and serious changes in the curve of crime if they reduce their reliance on the death penalty. Research has failed to provide scientific proof that executions have a greater deterrent effect than life imprisonment and such proof is unlikely to be forthcoming. The evidence as a whole gives no positive support to a deterrent hypothesis.”
The United States Supreme Court has concluded there is no apparent deterrence that can be related to the threat or enactment of the death penalty. In a democratic country, the cost of the death penalty is higher than life imprisonment.
We are aware of the pain, anger and suffering of the families and friends of the victims of violence and murder. We pledge to stand with them as they struggle to overcome the terrible loss and to find some sense of peace. We recognize that revenge and rage beget revenge and rage and the cycle of violence must be broken for both justice and peace to reign. Capital punishment does nothing for the families of victims of violent crime other than prolong their suffering through many wasted years of criminal proceedings. Rather than fueling their cry for vengeance, the state could better serve them by helping them come to terms with their grief. (United States Catholic Bishops statement on Capital Punishment. 1997)
We “are called to be a community of conscience within the large society and to test public life by the moral vision anchored in Scripture and consistent with the best of our nation’s founding ideals.” (United States Catholic Bishops statement: “Faithful Citizenship”)
As a society, we must struggle to find more humane, more hopeful and more effective responses to violent crime. Each of us bears responsibility to foster an attitude in a broader society, which affirms human life and rejects vengeance as a means of promoting justice. Ultimately the question before us should be: how do we best preserve human life and the dignity of all persons, while at the same time ensuring respect for law and the protection of our society? Our answer to this question will determine the kind of society we want to be. We seek a society of justice, not vengeance and violence. We believe a determined; though compassionate response to crime, that foregoes the violence of death penalty, is more consistent with a respect for all of human life It will better protect the rights of all persons. (Cardinal Joseph Bernardin – 1989)
Respect for all human life and the opposition to violence in our society are at the root of our long standing position against the death penalty. We see the death penalty as perpetuating a cycle of violence and promoting a sense of vengeance in our culture. We oppose the death penalty not just for what is does to those guilty of heinous crimes, but for what is does to all of us; it offers the tragic illusion that we can defend life by taking life. (Most Rev. Joseph Fiorenza, President of the National Conference of Catholic Bishops/United States Catholic Conference – 1999)
We urge governments to seek alternatives to the death penalty that reflect intelligence, civility, compassion and justice. Restoration of society and the healing of victims, as well as reform and rehabilitation of the offenders, must be the goals of a criminal justice system. We support the moratorium called for by Pope John Paul II in his 1998 Christmas address and the international initiative “Moratorium Now,” a movement organized to suspend all executions. We call on all governments to suspend the death penalty and to ratify the Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on civil and political rights on ending the death penalty.
The persons below have signed on to support this statement:
- Marta Inés Toro, OP, Provincial Councilor and Justice and Peace Promoter
- Dominican Sisters of the Presentation (Dighton) USA Province
- Anne Lythgoe, OP, Past President, Dominican Leadership Conference
- Mary Ellen Bennett, OP, President, Dominican Sisters of Elkins Park, PA
- The Intercommunity Center for Justice and Peace, NYC
- Mariana Wood, OP, Vicaress, Houston Dominican Sisters
- Michael J. Dodds, OP, Vicar, Western Dominican Province, USA
- Maryann Summa, OP, President, Dominican Sisters of Sparkill, NY
- Veronica Rafferty International Coordinator, Dominican Volunteers International
- Mrs.Druscilla Chauffe, OP, Moderator/President, Dominican Laity/St. Martin de Porres Province
- Susan Anne Snyder, OP, Prioress of the Congregation, Dominican Sisters of Kenosha, Wisconsin
- Neli Armas Tejera, OP, Delegada de Justicia y Paz, Congregación Romana de Santo Domingo, Chile
- Joyce Calagos, OPL, Dominican Laity Representative, North American Promoters for Justice and Peace
- Joan O´Shanahan, President of Codal, Confederation of Dominican Sisters, Latin America and the Caribbean
- Jude Siciliano, OP, Promoter of Preaching, Southern Dominican Province, USA
- Frances Thibodeau, OP, Provincial Councilor, Dominicans of the Roman Congregation
- Gene Poore, OP, Leadership Team, Councilor, Oxford Dominican Sisters
- Rose Marie Hennessy, OP, Prioress General, Dominican Sisters of Mission San Jose, CA
- Eileen Gannon, Main Representative, DLC/NGO
- Albert Judy, OP, Webfriar, Dominican Central